What Changed Between Riven’s CDs and DVD

Seventeen added Temple Island views, two deleted orphans, and eighty-nine edited cards between the 1997 five-CD release and the DVD edition

Players who moved from the original five-CD release of Riven (1997) to the DVD-ROM edition knew two things: the DVD carried higher-bitrate video plus a handful of extra views, and save files could not cross between the two editions (ScummVM still refuses a CD save on DVD data with incompatible game version - CD vs DVD). Yet the exact card-level differences were never cataloged in one place,1 and even in The Riven Diffs I could only note that card numbers shifted on Temple and Jungle Islands because cards had been added or removed. [Versions compared: the original English five-CD release of Riven 1.0 (data saved September 10–16, 1997; live checks on unmodified 1997 Macintosh 1.0) against the June 1998 DVD data master as reissued on the 2003 Ubisoft 10th Anniversary DVD (version 1.2). Card labels such as Temple:122 use 1.0 CD numbering and open that card in the Riven Graph.]

Because every card in Riven’s Mohawk archives carries a persistent RMAP identifier that survives renumbering, matching the eight archives card by card makes the entire diff transparent.

The Timeline of Riven’s Data Files

Inspecting the HFS timestamps, PE linker headers, and archive dates across the 1997 CDs, the November 1997 Windows 1.02 patch, and the 2003 DVD reissue shows that almost all of the DVD’s world-data edits were authored in June 1998, less than a year after launch:

DateMilestoneEvidence
September 10–16, 1997Riven 1.0 (five CDs)Base Mohawk archives saved (g_data, o_data, r_data on Sept 10; most on Sept 15; b_data, p_data on Sept 16); README dated September 15, 1997; Mac installer saved September 16.
November 12–17, 1997Windows 1.02 patchTwo overlay archives (B_DATA1, J_DATA3) patch scripts on three cards (Boiler:284, Jungle:255, Jungle:538) and water effects; all 26 base archives remain identical to 1.0.
June 3–17, 1998DVD data masterFifteen of the eighteen Mohawk archives change size; Temple Island’s data split across two archives (t_data2.mhk saved June 17). These 1998 archives carry straight onto the 2003 DVD.
July–September 200310th Anniversary DVD (1.2)New Mac executable (Riven DVD 1.2, July 18), readmes (July 21), Windows Riven.exe 1.2 (August 5), and a re-saved t_data1.mhk (September 30, the only 2003 data archive).

Matching 2,307 CD Cards to 2,322 DVD Cards

Each card’s hotspots and scripts can be canonicalized by replacing local card numbers with target RMAP codes and resolving variable, command, and hotspot names. [Scope of the diff: this comparison covers every card’s RMAP identity, hotspots, and bytecode scripts. Picture, movie, sound, and hotspot-toggle lists (PLST, MLST, SLST, BLST) and shared bitmaps were not exhaustively diffed here, though sample comparisons in The Riven Diffs found shared renders byte-for-byte identical, and both the Menu:1 title bitmap and all 17 added Temple Island renders were extracted directly from the DVD archives below.] Across all eight stacks (aspit, bspit, gspit, jspit, ospit, pspit, rspit, and tspit), the comparison breaks down cleanly:

CategoryCountDetails
Total cards on 1997 CD 1.02,307Baseline of The Riven Graph.
Total cards on DVD edition2,322Net change of +15 cards.
Shared cards (RMAP in both)2,3052,216 have identical hotspots and scripts; 89 differ.
Added on DVD only17All on Temple Island, each reached by a new up hotspot band.
Removed on DVD (CD only)2Both unreachable Jungle Island orphans (Jungle:249, Jungle:648).
Directed references added on DVD778 new edges between shared cards, 17 up entries, and 52 exits from the 17 new cards.
Directed references removed on DVD2The two exits of deleted Jungle:648 (→ 644, → 646).

This also explains the card-number shifts documented in The Riven Diffs. Six of the eight stacks keep identical card numbers across both editions. On Jungle Island, deleting Jungle:249 shifts DVD card numbers down by 1 starting at CD 250, and deleting Jungle:648 shifts them down by 2 starting at CD 649. On Temple Island, inserting 17 new cards pushes DVD numbers upward by 1 to 17 depending on position.

Seventeen New Look-Up Views on Temple Island

Every single card added on the DVD sits on Temple Island, and all seventeen follow the exact same pattern: an existing card gains a new horizontal up hotspot band across the top of the viewport, tilting the camera skyward to a new card with a down exit back to the ground and left/right turns to neighboring views. None of those seventeen cards has an up hotspot on the 1997 CDs.

You can test the first of them three steps from the opening cage: walk from Temple:155 → Temple:133 → Temple:127 → Temple:122 (card 122 in both editions) and move the pointer to the top strip of the sky (y < 51). On unmodified 1997 Macintosh 1.0, the cursor stays a plain forward hand and clicking walks ahead to Temple:129. On the DVD, the cursor turns into an upward hand and clicking opens DVD Temple:132, revealing the full Golden Dome rising above the rocky ridge.

Side-by-side comparison of Temple 122 on 1997 Macintosh Riven 1.0 CD and the DVD edition. On the left, hovering the top sky on the CD shows an ordinary forward hand with only the base of the Golden Dome peeking over the ridge. On the right, clicking that top band on the DVD tilts up to DVD Temple 132, showing the full Golden Dome against blue sky and white clouds.

Left: live 1997 Macintosh 1.0 CD at Temple:122, where the top edge carries no up hotspot (clicking walks forward to Temple:129). Right: DVD Temple:132, the new upward view reached from that band.

Extracting the primary tBMP bitmap of every one of the seventeen DVD-only cards from t_data1.mhk and t_data2.mhk confirms that all seventeen are genuine new upward views tracing the Golden Dome and Temple Island’s skyline—from the telescope platform, under the steam pipes, across the wooden bridge, and around the base of the dome itself. Fifteen of the seventeen carry RMAP identifiers above the highest RMAP in the CD’s Temple stack (0x24209, spanning 0x243b5 through 0x25304), consistent with cards authored specifically for the later master rather than cut before 1.0; only two (0x235f5 and 0x23d06, beside the telescope) fall below 0x24209.

Contact sheet showing all 17 DVD-only Temple Island look-up views extracted directly from the DVD Mohawk archives, labeled from Temple 122 to Temple 515. Every view tilts upward toward the Golden Dome, the wooden bridge, the steam pipes, or the Temple Island skyline against a blue sky.

All seventeen DVD-only cards extracted directly from the DVD archives (t_data1.mhk and t_data2.mhk), paired with the CD Temple Island card that gained the new up band.

CD parent cardDVD parentAdded DVD cardAdded RMAPParent scene name (CD)
Temple:1221221320x25304tislandexterior.550
Temple:1361371560x235f5tislandexterior.275
Temple:1371381460x23d06ttelescope1clsdup.300
Temple:1471491550x243b5ttlscp5poshiopn.475
Temple:3203243290x244cbtisext_hndldn.2600
Temple:3233273340x2460ctislandexterior.2700
Temple:3853914000x25106tislandexteriorbu.5050
Temple:3933994010x252d4tislandexteriorbu.4950
Temple:4114204220x248d2tislandexterior.2950
Temple:4134214240x24795tislandexterior.2850
Temple:4925025330x249f1tislandexterior.3950
Temple:4985085270x24ff0tislandexteriored.4125
Temple:5015115250x24e12tislandexteriorbu.4225
Temple:5045145160x24de8tislandexteriorbu.4325
Temple:5095205220x24cb0tislandexteriorbu.4425
Temple:5145285300x250f6tislandexteriored.4050
Temple:5155295310x24b8ftislandexteriored.3990

Two Deleted Orphans on Jungle Island

Only two cards from the 1997 five-CD release have no RMAP counterpart on the DVD, and both were already flagged as unreachable development remnants in The Riven Graph, 2:

  • Jungle:249 (RMAP 0x2e358): an isolated card holding the stone circle with the Tay book niche open—an early single-state card superseded once Jungle:213 held both closed and open states. Its three hotspots (left, forward, right) had empty scripts.
  • Jungle:648 (RMAP 0xc372): an unreachable lagoon beach view with two working turns (left → Jungle:646, right → Jungle:644) and two empty forward hotspots. Removing it also removes the only two directed edges present on the CD and absent from the DVD.

Side-by-side renders of the two Jungle Island cards present on the 1997 CDs and deleted from the DVD. Left, Jungle 249 shows the ring of stone totems with the Tay book niche standing open in the far wall. Right, Jungle 648 shows a sunlit sandy lagoon beach with palm trees and stone stairs.

The only two cards removed between the 1997 five-CD release and the DVD: Jungle:249 (left) and Jungle:648 (right).

Cyan’s decision to delete these exact two cards on the DVD confirms that both were genuine leftovers rather than hidden destinations.

Three Zip Mode Edits

Three shared cards change their Zip Mode hotspots (flags=1, cursor 1002) between CD and DVD—one shortcut removed and two added:

Side-by-side hotspot comparison of the Zip Mode edits between CD and DVD. Left, Prison 29 after Catherine’s rescue with a red dashed rectangle over the broken overhead handle marking HSPT 14 pcell, present only on CD 1.0. Right, Garden 12 inside Survey Island’s fountain elevator with a green dashed square over the left wall button marking HSPT 11 gfountelevup, added on the DVD.

The two ends of Riven’s Zip Mode revision: HSPT 14 on Prison:29 (left) was deleted on the DVD, while HSPT 11 on Garden:12 (right, paired with Garden:13 upstairs) was added.

1. Removed on Prison:29

On the 1997 CDs, HSPT 14 (ΩpcellΩ, [418, 0, 526, 29]) stayed permanently active on top of the broken elevator handle after Catherine’s rescue, letting Zip Mode teleport you straight back into Prison:32 to watch Catherine walk past the bars again—an oddity previously documented by players in 1998–1999.2 On the DVD, HSPT 14 is deleted completely, sealing the shaft once the handle breaks. For the complete end-to-end playthrough, script analysis, and Catherine’s post-rescue idle timer inside her cell, see Catherine Is Still in Her Cell.

2. Added on Garden:12 and Garden:13

Inside Survey Island’s fountain elevator, the 1997 CD forces you to watch the full elevator ride in both directions even with Zip Mode enabled. The DVD adds HSPT 11 over the elevator button on both floors (ΩgfountelevupΩ at [33, 300, 45, 313] on Garden:12, and ΩgfountelevdnΩ at [33, 301, 46, 314] on Garden:13) so Zip Mode skips the ride.

Outside the seventeen up bands and three Zip edits, sixty-nine other shared cards differ between the CD and DVD masters. Several are visible right at the title screen or fix concrete gameplay bugs.

Redesigned Title Screen (Menu:1)

On the 1997 CDs, the title screen (Menu:1) shows only two right-aligned labels—SETUP (HSPT 22) and PLAY RIVEN (HSPT 16)—so restoring a saved game requires starting or using the menu bar. On the DVD, Cyan re-lettered Menu:1 with three wider labels shifted left—SETUP, START NEW GAME, and START SAVED GAME—adding HSPT 23 ([485, 283, 602, 300]) calling xarestoregame, an external command that no 1.0 CD script invokes.

Side-by-side comparison of Menu 1 title screens extracted from the 1997 CD and the DVD with hotspot boxes outlined. Left, CD 1.0 displays the Riven emblem with two labels, Setup and Play Riven. Right, the DVD displays Setup, Start New Game, and a new green-outlined third button, Start Saved Game, wired to HSPT 23 xarestoregame.

Title screen (Menu:1) extracted from the 1997 CD (left) and the DVD (right), with hotspot rectangles overlaid.

One-Digit Submarine Dock Fix (Jungle:406)

Inside the Jungle-to-Survey maglev car (Jungle:406), clicking the lever to depart for Survey Island resets the submarine if you left it parked at dock 3 (jsub == 3, the gallows dock), moving it back to dock 1 (jsub = 0). On the 1997 CD, the script mistakenly extended bridge 2 instead of bridge 1; the DVD fixes the one-digit variable typo:

// Jungle:406 (HSPT 8, departing for Survey Island while jsub == 3)
// 1997 CD 1.0:
  jsub = 0;
  jbridge2 = 1;
  jsubdir = 0;
  jsubhatch = 0;

// DVD edition:
  jsub = 0;
  jbridge1 = 1;
  jsubdir = 0;
  jsubhatch = 0;

Eight directed edges between cards that already existed on the 1997 CDs were wired up only on the DVD, mostly turning dead-end look-up views into navigable angles:

Side-by-side comparison of Temple 406 and Temple 412 with DVD additions outlined in green. Left, the Great Bridge steam valve at Temple 406 where hotspot tbookvalveoff transitions to Temple 412 on the DVD. Right, the Great Bridge sky view at Temple 412 with new left and right turn strips added on the DVD.

The Great Bridge valve (Temple:406, left) and sky view (Temple:412, right): on the DVD, turning tbookvalveoff pans directly to Temple:412, which gains side turns to Temple:411 and Temple:406.

Two further cards—Jungle:163 (wiring empty HSPT 8 into HSPT 9 → Jungle:160) and Temple:506 (wiring empty HSPT 8 into HSPT 10 → Temple:513)—activate auxiliary forward rectangles pointing to destinations already reachable from HSPT 3.

Complete Breakdown of All 89 Edited Shared Cards

Every one of the 89 edited shared cards falls into one of eight disjoint groups:

CategoryCardsWhat changed on the DVD
Temple up look-up bands17New up hotspot band on each of the 17 Temple Island cards listed above (with Temple:393 also adjusting its forward rectangle).
Zip Mode edits3Removed ΩpcellΩ on Prison:29; added fountain-elevator Zip shortcuts on Garden:12 and Garden:13.
Completed navigation hotspots6Boiler:226, Jungle:478, Jungle:552, Temple:402 (new card edges); Jungle:163, Temple:506 (wired auxiliary forward zones).
Rolled-in Windows 1.02 patch3Boiler:284, Jungle:255, and Jungle:538 fold in the November 1997 B_DATA1/J_DATA3 script updates.
Script logic, UI, and timing16Menu:1 adds Start Saved Game (HSPT 23, calling xarestoregame); Jungle:406 fixes jbridge2 → jbridge1; Temple:406/412 rewrite the Great Bridge animation and side turns; Temple:155 trims two 2000/3000 ms opening delays; Gehn:1 sets obutton = 1 on card_enter when agehn == 1 and atrapbook == 1; Jungle:769 adds xjschool280_resetleft/right; plus smaller script, cursor, or movie tweaks on Garden:229, Jungle:143, Jungle:450, Gehn:77, Temple:152, Temple:191, Temple:221, Temple:355, and Temple:376.
Inert template hotspots stripped16Script-less leftover zones deleted on 14 cards—including all seven blank-card template hotspots on Gehn:89 and Prison:46 noted in The Riven Graph, 2, plus Boiler:164, 448, Garden:235, Jungle:259, 331, 600, 703, 714, Rebel:14, 16, Temple:289, and 309—and empty up handlers removed on Boiler:170 and Rebel:34.
Hotspots renamed to null9Blank or forward non-navigating hotspots renamed to null on Jungle:86, 279, 546, Gehn:12, 14, and Temple:200, 203, 252, 254.
Sound-index shifts19play_sound IDs shift by −1 on three Survey cards (Garden:263–265) and by +1 across sixteen Jungle cards (Jungle:573, 589, 591–594, 631, 633, 634, 728–732, 741, 743), reflecting reindexed tWAV tables.

Conclusion

The DVD edition of Riven is mostly remembered for fitting five discs onto one and upgrading the video compression, yet its Mohawk scripts tell a quieter story of post-launch craftsmanship. Between September 1997 and June 1998, Cyan went back through Temple Island to add seventeen upward views of its skyline and Golden Dome, deleted two stranded Jungle cards and sixteen cards’ worth of template clutter, fixed a lingering Zip Mode escape hatch on Prison Island and a submarine-dock typo on Jungle Island, wired up eight missing camera turns, and added a direct Start Saved Game button to the title screen. Everything else—2,216 of the 2,305 shared cards—remained untouched.


  1. Contemporary fan sites did note individual surface fixes on the DVD—such as the Survey Island maglev door closing on departure (Nitpicking Guide to Riven, Riven Illuminated) and the village lagoon submarine no longer disappearing after the villagers flee (Riven Illuminated)—without a card-by-card comparison. ↩︎

  2. Documented on two archived late-1990s GeoCities sites: Nitpicking Guide to Riven (1998–1999) and Riven Illuminated (October 1999; mirrored at Myst Archive). Neither site noted that Cyan deleted the hotspot on the DVD. ↩︎